A Place in The Sun: The Desperate Cowers.

"SINKING DESPERATION" That's what I would title this scene from 1951's "A PLACE IN THE SUN ". I say that metaphorical boat capsized long before the physical one lunged itself and them into the achingly cold depths of the river. The weight of their hidden desires, longing, and unsatisfied ambitions sunk it, the water just hadn't figured it's way in yet. Shelley Winters packs so much wide-eyed hope and hopelessness into a few looks she makes it as hard for the audience to look at her fully as Montgomery Clift's George Eastman.

017 A Place In The Sun (1951).jpg

Her ambition, want, desire, hope is nowhere near as free as George’s, as a woman it is bottled up everywhere in her body so as not to offend, except her eyes. There she's got a laser beam focused directly on George, burning all the hope, all the want, the pain of being seen for once in that lonely isolated factory , in this lonely town of lopsided privilege, where the men grow, and fulfill promise, and move on, gifting their eyes, their belief, to the Angela Vickers of the world, who seem to have it all, and want even what little happiness you have found. Winters with one look of sad, near pathetic longing burns the disappointment of believing in the promise of the George Eastman’s only then to be altogether tossed away with a baby now in tow with such little regard, by a man who himself is so little as to beg for regard by those who have so little for him, born of nothing more than the idea of who he is. She sees him, and she wants so wantonly for him to see her. Winters with her eyes only, gives one last plea into the darkness of inevitability and futility, asking George to not so much forget what he doesn’t have, as remember what he does. She is delivering her closing argument, in the cause of George Eastman vs the world, presenting her case with modesty that everything might just be okay as long as they the have-nots stick together. “Let’s drift for awhile I’m not afraid of the dark”.

a tense and well played scene in the boat on the lake

The line has double meaning, and it is co-signed by body language, Winters is erect and still in the boat, sure of their trajectory regardless of the direction or quality of the boat. The more unresponsive George is, the more desperate her plea, the more urgent. She begins to lean forward with intent, her hand begin to space apart, her eyes are widening. Winters projects her energy forward, towards George, acute and straining. It's as if Montgomery Clift is Bond asking if Winters expects him to talk , and Winters is yelling out "No Mr Eastman, I expect you to FEEEL!". Except there is no true villain here , and if there is it's most certainly not Winters Alice Tripp. Its Clift’s Eastman, all repression and no accountability, facing downward, and away from Winters, restrained, but reactionary, and impulsive.

Screen Shot 2019-09-25 at 12.35.25 PM.png

So that he throws their boat over with the weight of the indecision expressed in his movement. He tips that boat with his inability to be moved, both emotionally and figuratively. George causes the imbalance, the boat capsizes, and it is Clift’s exactness of expression, the furrowed brow, the downcast eyes, the restless energy, the crumpled, folded nature of each of his stillness, that allows us to believe that this was a crime not of passionate action, but dispassionate inaction. His inability to decide even, as he had decided, to move , even though he desires to be anywhere but here, to speak even though he has so much to say, is the death of Shelley Winters Alice Tripp. Clift is the embodiment of male impotency, death by analysis, all desire, no action, no follow through. It’s hellified, bone-marrow acting done with superb accuracy and intelligence, a supremely well constructed, perfect scene in an extremely flawed movie about extremely flawed characters.