The Disappearance of Diahann Carroll
/Its crazy because when I heard, or rather read and then heard, because the words became so deafeningly loud in my head - “Diahann Carroll has died” , My mind began instantly searching for something beyond the obligatory “Oh My God” you'd think..I'd think that as my mind turned over all my retrospective files on this woman’s career, I would immediately envision her sturdy brilliance in "Claudine" or maybe her part in one of my favorite dance numbers ever in Carmen Jones ( and that one eyebrow), let me not forget her role as Whitley’s mother Marion (in which she she basically played a version of Lynn Whitfield’s Matriarch that added her own unique flavor ) or her extremely memorable work in Robert Townsend's The Five Heartbeats playing a version of herself so committed she nearly tears through the silver screen in every scene…
But it wasn’t any of those roles that came to mind, in fact Diahann almost ceased to exist, and when I called for her in their stead, in her stead, the first image in my mind was of Elzora - Carroll’s small, but immensely effective and affective role in Kasi Lemmons " Eve's Bayou". Upon reflecting about it further it becomes easier for me to see why this stood out to me first. It’s soulful, its complex, its involves the best elements of transformation which are neither cheap or exploitive. Contextually Carroll's Witch is the underside of this black Haven. The embodied ghost of still disenfranchised members of families left behind or rolled over by privileged racist whites, and ambitious African-Americans who had the right amount of color, resolve, ruthlessness, or all of the above to climb out of their social dungeons. Physically Diahann Carroll brings revelation outside the margins of the scene, just as much as she does in scene. On one side she is Diahann Carroll Queen of elegance, unrivaled put togetherness, and “You Tried it” energy. On the netherside of that she is almost completely hidden by white make-up, strands of unkempt silver hair, and a mask of concrete surliness. Eve’s Bayou allows her to slink back into a side of her that largely went unexplored before it. She moves differently, as if each appendage has to cut though weighted space to get to where it's going. When you watch closely you see she has moments where she seems to have spells where she's lost herself, her bearings, her thoughts, and then she just returns. In this scene as well as later with Jurnee Smollet’s Eve, she is callous, but also warm, and Carroll turns it on and off in screen with such intuitive and adept understanding of when the one energy is needed over the other she creates an integral bit of mortar that glues the various bricks of southern life that form the gothic and loving house of memory and loss Lemmons built. Every choice she made in that film supported a comprehensive whole….
It’s a link to a forgotten figure in black communes, the wise woman or witch. Elzora is a tie to pre- christian practices of black peoples, and to the strength, power, and position these women held within those communities. What Carroll gives her is her sense of gravitas, and a regality, that belies a sense of past ancestral grandeur. What she sacrifices in the embers of this visually striking portrayal is the grandiosity that served as the inertia for so may of her other roles. It is this exact sacrifice of what powers your mega wattage as a star to the gods of thespians, that makes you more than just a star. Once you can make your Clark Kent every bit as powerful and resonant as your superman, well you’re in the most elite company of actors. This is why I love this role so much, it was so much in so little. It was an underdog role for an underdog character whom was made powerful both by the implicit nature of the script and by the explicit nature of Carroll’s performance. It was representative of all Carroll was capable of, of all she could do, of all many black women could do, but especially those with her raw and exceptional talents. She did just about everything you could do in an industry where so many do so little, if anything at all. She had an impact that couldn’t be argued, through it was sufficiently less than she deserved. In a way Carroll was the Queen that is both clearly in power, and yet under duress, and under-served, who is gone now resting in that very power. Extending her roots, raising the ground for future actors, (and black actresses especially) to stand toe to toe with their rightful peers.
A Place in The Sun: The Desperate Cowers.
/"SINKING DESPERATION" That's what I would title this scene from 1951's "A PLACE IN THE SUN ". I say that metaphorical boat capsized long before the physical one lunged itself and them into the achingly cold depths of the river. The weight of their hidden desires, longing, and unsatisfied ambitions sunk it, the water just hadn't figured it's way in yet. Shelley Winters packs so much wide-eyed hope and hopelessness into a few looks she makes it as hard for the audience to look at her fully as Montgomery Clift's George Eastman.
Her ambition, want, desire, hope is nowhere near as free as George’s, as a woman it is bottled up everywhere in her body so as not to offend, except her eyes. There she's got a laser beam focused directly on George, burning all the hope, all the want, the pain of being seen for once in that lonely isolated factory , in this lonely town of lopsided privilege, where the men grow, and fulfill promise, and move on, gifting their eyes, their belief, to the Angela Vickers of the world, who seem to have it all, and want even what little happiness you have found. Winters with one look of sad, near pathetic longing burns the disappointment of believing in the promise of the George Eastman’s only then to be altogether tossed away with a baby now in tow with such little regard, by a man who himself is so little as to beg for regard by those who have so little for him, born of nothing more than the idea of who he is. She sees him, and she wants so wantonly for him to see her. Winters with her eyes only, gives one last plea into the darkness of inevitability and futility, asking George to not so much forget what he doesn’t have, as remember what he does. She is delivering her closing argument, in the cause of George Eastman vs the world, presenting her case with modesty that everything might just be okay as long as they the have-nots stick together. “Let’s drift for awhile I’m not afraid of the dark”.
The line has double meaning, and it is co-signed by body language, Winters is erect and still in the boat, sure of their trajectory regardless of the direction or quality of the boat. The more unresponsive George is, the more desperate her plea, the more urgent. She begins to lean forward with intent, her hand begin to space apart, her eyes are widening. Winters projects her energy forward, towards George, acute and straining. It's as if Montgomery Clift is Bond asking if Winters expects him to talk , and Winters is yelling out "No Mr Eastman, I expect you to FEEEL!". Except there is no true villain here , and if there is it's most certainly not Winters Alice Tripp. Its Clift’s Eastman, all repression and no accountability, facing downward, and away from Winters, restrained, but reactionary, and impulsive.
So that he throws their boat over with the weight of the indecision expressed in his movement. He tips that boat with his inability to be moved, both emotionally and figuratively. George causes the imbalance, the boat capsizes, and it is Clift’s exactness of expression, the furrowed brow, the downcast eyes, the restless energy, the crumpled, folded nature of each of his stillness, that allows us to believe that this was a crime not of passionate action, but dispassionate inaction. His inability to decide even, as he had decided, to move , even though he desires to be anywhere but here, to speak even though he has so much to say, is the death of Shelley Winters Alice Tripp. Clift is the embodiment of male impotency, death by analysis, all desire, no action, no follow through. It’s hellified, bone-marrow acting done with superb accuracy and intelligence, a supremely well constructed, perfect scene in an extremely flawed movie about extremely flawed characters.
MANDY IS JUST MY KIND OF MOVIE
/Couple of things you should know about me and movie going. A. That I tend to grade on a curve whenever I feel someone who is trying to deliver something truly (keyword truly) unique. And I'm not talking about that kind of person that seeks to be smarter than their audience or surpass their colleagues with something way more clever than they believe their peers ever could have dreamed of. And definitely not that person that seeks to only arrive to us with merely a unique concept and clearly no follow through on that great concept (and Yes, I'm talking to you hotel Artemis) . No, I'm talking about that person, with whom while watching their film you can almost feel that childlike energy, that kinetic, furious, passionate, barely contained fire, - if at all - that drives every one of us whenever we stumble upon an idea that will not loosen its grip upon our imagination. The kind that makes me imagine the writer director of this film being possessed sitting there at their desk, eyes jittering from side to side, just scribbling away incessantly, unable to stop themselves from leaping from word to word, sentence to sentence, page to page, action to action - whether or not that's what actually happens. B. I'm an experience type of reviewer and movie goer I'm big on my experience, I'm not necessarily a technical movie goer. I understand film theory, I understand the importance of structure, and often times I can see the lacking of it in a film in which my experience is already a poor one. But as I said before, if I am already immensely enjoying my film experience in your movie I am a teacher grading on an immense curve. All of a sudden willing to toss aside how believable your film might be, how riddled with plot holes your film might be, how detestable your characters might be, how lacking in technical proficiency your film might be. Because ultimately I was too enamored with how beautiful your film was, how much your film wooed me, how much it made overtures to my various senses, how much it enchanted me. How your actors mesmerized me, how scared I was, how much I may have laughed, how much I may have cried. If my experience feels more like a positive one than a negative one, I can forgive cardinal sins in structure, and I can somewhat put to the side - let's be honest maybe “a lot of what” put to the side - film theory for a second and just bathe in the glow of being thoroughly entertained for a couple hours or more. Mandy was such a movie.
Panos Cosmotos's wild blend of nostalgia, video games, fantasy, and rock and roll, with a committed Nicholas Cage front and center. Cosmotos movie does not nail it for me politically. In fact, in many other cases, I probably be sitting here writing about how it's just another woman in the fridge type story using its woman, the namesake infact of the movie as a convenient excuse to take us on a journey of male aggression, gratuitous violence, and anarchy. But I'm not writing about that because the story was too wild, the colors too gorgeous, Nicholas cage's performance too balls to the wall insane and committed and vainglorious. All of this in a two hour heap of dismembered bodies, exaggerated over the top monologues, and primal screams. Cosmotos brings us both something we've seen before, or at least know of and yet something wholly original. A movie where I ultimately knew what was going to happen within the first thirty minutes of the film and yet I also was made to feel like I had no clue as to what would happen next from one sequence to the next through the entire duration of the film, right up until the ending, it's typical and yet wholly unique.
It reminded me of so many of those books I used to love as a kid. Books inspired, and clearly influenced by and from authors like Tolkien, or Herbert, or Robert E Howard's Conan pulp. But nowhere near as good in the execution. They usually grabbed me with a well illustrated cover, and an eye catching title (Im making all of these up) like ; The Gates of Baldermoor, The Dragons of Huron, Time and Shadows volume one. I also gleamed portions of the film as being inspired by Ralph Bashki's underrated animation film heavy metal or at that least aesthetically influenced by it. It harkened me back to a time of cult leaders and a time when devil worshipers were the worst of us. And while it had me on an IV drip of nostalgia, it fed me on a, steady diet of arresting visuals, outstanding camera work, and a manic, unpredictable, rabid performance by Nicholas Cage, and Linus Roache, that kept circling two words around my head, tigers blood and dragon juice. Because that's how bat shit crazy and amazing it was.
I'm writing more about the experience than the technical aspects of this movie, because I believe that that ultimately is what Mandy is...the movie going experience. Rather than a movie you go into toting your experience. I really couldn't tell you how technically proficient, it may or may not be because somewhere along the road I just got lost in the proverbial sauce. It was fun, it was outrageous. It was visually poetic. It was nostalgia based, without using the nostalgia as a crutch. There were some pacing troubles near the end there, and Mandy, the movie's namesake was unfortunately not truly apart of this film in any meaningful way beyond being a prop for Nicolas Cage's unhinged rage fest. That was maybe the only real disappointment and I don't want to minimize it. Mandy did a lot of things really really well and while I thoroughly enjoyed myself watching it. I felt like this movie could have moved beyond a cult classic to an actual masterpiece had it featured more about Mandy and rooted her to the story in more than name. Not only would it have begotten more interesting narrative choices, but considering her condition, I think you would have had a movie with some very interesting, even if accidental commentary. And something, ultimately, that I think would have moved beyond its sort of superficial in all the best ways, cult feel, and right into pantheon of Film making.
As it stands Cosmotos film is a movie that raises an eyebrow and makes you sit up and forward in your seat. I think if he builds upon this, this may be a director to watch in the future, and although I can't recommend Mandy for everyone those of you who like me, like it when you stumble upon something so interesting and so one of its kind, that you tend to grade the movie on a curve and never mind the devil in the details, then this is also definitely your movie.